
I like upscale as much as the next person, so when my friend Roberta asked if I wanted to go to the new Wayfare Tavern I didn't hesitate. Designated as the flagship of Tyler Florence's restaurant empire, it is the hot spot of the FiDi right now. On a Monday night at 7pm it was packed. We had a 7:30 res, and with two of us there at 7:15 and a third person (Ms. Christine) joining us at 7:20, it was almost 8pm when we were seated.
While waiting at the bar, we ordered a 209 Martini (13) and a Hot Brandy (8). The tender must have been new to either bar tending or SF, because he didn't know what a hot brandy was; he put a snifter of brandy on its side in a cup of hot water! He also added a mystery ingredient to my martini and it wasn't vermouth. Because it was busy and I was with company, I didn't say anything, but I intend to go back and have a discussion with the manager.
After being seated, we were served some nice warm popovers with butter, compliments of the house. To get the ball rolling, some Angels On Horseback (11), California dates wrapped in smoked bacon, with fennel garlic puree and a raisin caper salsa verde. This is a nice variation on the traditional use of oysters. But here also is that pet peeve of mine - why five pieces? Why not six? Grilled Monterrey Bay Calamari (9) came with toasted garlic, squid ink vinaigrette, smoked chile oil, breadcrumbs and celery. Perfectly cooked, tender and moist, this didn't really knock me out but my cohorts seemed to enjoy it.
Christine ordered the Braised Beef Short Ribs (27) served with potato puree, black pepper creme fraiche, Bosc pear, truffle and celery. This beef comes from a farm in Four Story Hills, New Jersey, and Ms. C. said it was fantastic and almost more than she could handle. I'm actually getting hungry just looking at the picture here.
Roberta went with the Roast Liberty Farms Duck, Hunter's Style (25), coupled with parsnip puree, prunes, bacon lardon, Cipollini onions, chicory and red wine jus. Again, no complaints from her corner. Nice portion of duck, skillful blending of flavors.
Yours truly felt the need for beef and I chose the Grilled Santa Maria Tri-Tip (26), with roasted heirloom onion, truffle butter and Kennebec French Fries. I remember when you almost couldn't give tri-tip away, it being a tough piece of meat to cook if you didn't have patience and you didn't know how to slice it. I can say they definitely know how to do both at Wayfare Tavern. I could have used about half the amount of fries, but that's how they roll in SF these days. They were nice and crispy and I didn't even need ketchup.
To help ease all this goodness down into the old gullet, a beautiful 2008 Ridge East Bench Zinfandel (52). Ridge has been one of my fave wineries (along with Caymus and Burgess Cellars) since the 70's, and this particular vintage paired wonderfully with all the entrees.
The ladies decided to forgo dessert, opting for a last glass of wine - Oberon Sauvignon Blanc (8) for Roberta, and Bucklin Zinfandel (12) for Christine. I had to try the Fried Apple Pie (9) only because it came with sage ice cream. The wait between the apps and the entrees was a bit long, and then it took twenty minutes to get my dessert. I'd also ordered an espresso to come with the pie, and we had to ask two different people where that was. Our server was charming and knowledgeable and it was busy, but still, this is supposed to be a first class restaurant.I should have those cute little noise level symbols like The Bauer, but let's just say it was LOUD, more so at the bar area than at table. Roberta's friend was responsible for all the interior design and decor, and I must say it's all dark wood and Americana, with Fall being the general theme right now.
So, thumbs up on the food, an asi-asi on the service. Definitely the place for that power lunch, but perhaps not that intimate date.
To see the full menu, go to: www.wayfaretavern.com























































